The
markets are inundated with self-help books. 100 Desi Stories to
Inspire You by Madhur Zakir Hallengua is an addition to the same. The
stories are classified under the heads creativity, innovation,
teamwork, leadership, love, courage, maturity, confidence and human
emotions.
The
reasoning behind the acts of the characters in the stories is kept
under the wraps and the reader is first asked to guess about the
same. Then follows the explanations called answers for their
behaviour. The writing is simple without the use of any jargons. The
stories are too short often not more than a page or two. They are
narrated plainly and are predictable. I liked the stories The
Little Pricks of Life and The Adopted Child from the book.
Though
the author claims to have written all these stories, the fact remains
that we have already heard or read these stories somewhere or the
other. So they aren’t original. Again, I feel that books will have
to rated considering the audience for whom they are written. If 100
Desi Stories to Inspire You was written for children, I would have
still called it a good book. For an adult audience it is preachy and
insipid. The stories though loaded with moral lessons are banal.
The
book claims to contain inspirational stories. In the story Let Me
Die Instead of Him, a grandmother prays to God to take her life
instead of her sick grandson’s. When God comes to take her instead
of her grandson, she tells God to spare her life and take her sick
grandson’s life. Now what kind of inspiration does this story
provide?
Writing
self-help or inspirational book is not an easy task. As I always say
self-help books work for two reasons. One they promise magical
results. Two they establish strong emotional connect with the
readers. They should strike a chord with the reader and preach
without a preachy tone. 100 Desi Stories to Inspire You fails this
test. Still it may be an ideal gift for a school going kid, but not
for adults for sure.
Hi Mahesh, nice review that was.
ReplyDeleteI am currently blogging on Ramayan by sage Valmiki, you can visit my blogs- http://srirom.blogspot.in